Business Law: Principles for Today's Commercial Environment 3rd Edition by Marianne Moody Jennings, David Twomey, Marianne Jennings

Exercise 17

Master Mfg., Inc., contracted with Accur Computer Repair Corp. to maintain Master's computer system. Master's manufacturing process depends on its computer system operating properly at all times. A liquidated damages clause in the contract provided that Accur pay $1,000 to Master for each day that Accur was late responding to a service request. On January 12, Accur was notified that Master's computer system had failed. Accur did not respond to Master's service request until January 15. If Master sues Accur under the liquidated damages provision of the contract, Master will:
a. Win, unless the liquidated damage provision is determined to be a penalty
b. Win, because under all circumstances liquidated damages provisions are enforceable
c. Lose, because Accur's breach was not material d. Lose, because liquidated damage provisions violate public policy (5/93, Law, #25)