Exam 11: Concluding Thoughts
What political changes might help improve California government's long-term viability? In other words,how might some of California's political problems be solved through political reform?
Varies.There is no "correct" answer to this open-ended question,but students are prompted to consider the flaws that have been pointed out throughout the book and to suggest alternative arrangements that could make a difference for governing.The question is not asking about increasing funding in areas that are currently underfunded,which could apply broadly to many areas of government (the courts,for example),or types of governments (special districts,cities,school districts,etc. ).Rather,students should focus on possible rules changes in any number of areas,including: direct democracy (suggestions were listed in Chapter 3 with respect to the initiative process),the legislature (rules pertaining to budgeting,lawmaking,professionalization of the legislature,term limits),the executive branch (its organization,term limits,relative authority of the governor and a plural executive),courts (judicial elections),prisons,and criminal justice (relieving overcrowding through altering mandatory sentencing laws,reclassifying certain crimes,etc. ).
Setting aside policy issues,name three ways that California politics are "exceptional," meaning that it is the only state or one of only a few states to share these characteristics.
Varies.California's status as an economic generator and global powerhouse sets it apart;its annual budget is larger than that of many countries.At almost 40 million,the population is large and "hyperdiverse," which multiplies the types of demands that people place on government.California is not unique in having a hybrid government,but citizens use the process today more frequently than citizens in any other state.Through direct democracy,a governor was recalled (only the second in U.S.history and the first in California history).The state legislature is professionalized,resembling the U.S.Congress in form and function,and members are term limited,creating regular turnover and musical chairs among elective offices.California has a plural executive like most states,but a fairly powerful governor because she/he has a role to play on the world stage,because of California's economic status.Elections in California are also exceptional: the Top-Two primary (jungle primary)creates much intraparty competition,and allows independents to take part in elections,and enables all registered voters to select from among all candidates--an unusual arrangement among the states.The Citizens Redistricting Commission is likewise exceptional,although several other states (13)have similar commissions with primary responsibility for redistricting,denying the state legislature a major role.The state's "permissive" voter registration rules,such as those that make it easier for people to register (vote-by-mail;same-day registration;motor voter;online registration;pre-registration for 16- and 17-year olds),set it apart.Moving to an all vote-by-mail system will also make the state's election system different (only three other states conduct all elections by mail).The progressive or leftist political leanings have resulted in a preference for Democratic officials;although the state only has a plurality of Democrats by registration,a supermajority of Democrats were elected to the state legislature (in both chambers)in 2012 and 2016,and they controlled both the executive and legislative branches.The shrinking Republican minority (at 26%)is the smallest in state history.A plethora of special districts also makes it exceptional;local governments with responsibility for providing services abound.California's unfunded liabilities,or debt,which ranges past $300 billion,also place it in a category all its own.(Certain taxes are also high,such as the gas tax and income taxes on the wealthiest,but California does not have "the highest taxes" among the U.S.states;rates vary by purpose. )This list is not comprehensive,and students might also discern other ways that California's politics diverge from the other states.
What kinds of political issues will California elected officials uniquely face in the coming decades?
Varies.Among many other issues (only a few prominent "headliner" issues are mentioned in Chapter 11),California politicians will need to consider how to adequately prepare and educate a workforce for the coming century;how to accommodate a large population of retired persons who put tremendous demands and stresses on health-care systems;how to deal with immigrant populations,who tend to vote less than other ethnic groups but who are a majority in the state,around 2.5 million of whom are undocumented;how to deal with environmental challenges resulting from climate change,a trend that has direct impacts on water availability,sea life and activity,life on the coast,and life in other sensitive areas (dry forests and heightened fire conditions,etc. );effects from prolonged drought (even if above-ground aquifers are refilled through heavy rains),such as preparing for the next drought with more storage and delivery capacity,repairing damage to infrastructure caused by depleted groundwater supplies,and addressing damage to ecosystems;and how to revitalize its aging infrastructure,which will require an estimated $500 billion of investment.
In what ways is California "different" from the rest of the nation? How do these differences give rise to politics that are uniquely challenging or "exceptional"?
What major social developments will significantly affect politics in California during the next 10-20 years?
The text suggests that California politics is "riddled with paradoxes." What is paradoxical about politics in California?
"Effective governance" has many dimensions,but one way to define it is as follows: a good fit exists between the demands of the people and what their institutions deliver;decision makers understand their constituents' needs and respond responsibly to them;and representatives grasp the dimensions of pressing problems or unanticipated events and devise fair,responsible,and timely solutions that make economic sense.Is California "effectively" governed? Considering the definition provided here,devise a short list of criteria for evaluating what "effective governance" means,and construct an argument about how well California state government measures up.
Imagine that you have the time and money to propose a ballot initiative to reform California government.In simple terms,what is your idea? How would it solve a particular problem without creating more? Consider the consequences of your reform and place it in historical context.Finally,what are the chances for its passage?
Filters
- Essay(0)
- Multiple Choice(0)
- Short Answer(0)
- True False(0)
- Matching(0)