Exam 2: Learning Moral Lessons From Stories
Chapter 2 mentions several ways to use narratives to explore ethics. Which of the following is NOT one of these?
C
Compare and contrast Plato's and Aristotle's views on whether watching a dramatic play, or in today's world, a film, has a positive or a negative influence. Compare their viewpoints to the current discussion about violence in films and on television. In your opinion, is one of the two viewpoints more accurate than the other? Why or why not?
Plato and Aristotle had differing views on the influence of dramatic plays and films. Plato believed that dramatic plays and poetry could have a negative influence on individuals, as they could evoke strong emotions and lead to irrational behavior. He was concerned that these art forms could lead people to become too emotionally involved and lose touch with reality. On the other hand, Aristotle believed that dramatic plays and poetry could have a positive influence, as they provided a cathartic release for emotions and allowed individuals to experience and understand different perspectives.
In today's world, the discussion about violence in films and on television mirrors the debate between Plato and Aristotle. Some argue that exposure to violent content in media can desensitize individuals and lead to aggressive behavior, while others believe that it can serve as a form of catharsis and provide a means for individuals to explore and understand the complexities of human nature.
In my opinion, both viewpoints have merit. While it is important to recognize the potential negative influence of violent media, it is also important to acknowledge the potential for catharsis and understanding that these art forms can provide. Ultimately, the impact of dramatic plays, films, and television on individuals is complex and multifaceted, and cannot be reduced to a simple binary of positive or negative influence. It is important for individuals to critically engage with media and for creators to be mindful of the potential impact of their work.
Fairy tales at the time when the Grimm brothers collected the stories were folktales that were told primarily by adults to children.
There is a sharp distinction between factual and fictional stories.
Aristotle viewed art as dangerous because it inspired violent emotions.
There is a difference between stories that moralize and stories that discuss moral problems.
List movies that seem to embody the story archetypes of the bargain, the good twin and the bad twin, and the quest.
NASA is trying to create exciting stories about space exploration in the hope that such novels can awaken an interest in space and science among young people.
The Trobriand people distinguish between three different kinds of stories. Which one does NOT belong on the list?
Discuss the phenomenon of Goethe's novel about Werther, a young man who commits suicide because of unrequited love: What were the effects of the publication? Why did this phenomenon happen? Do you think something similar could happen today, because of the inspiration of a film, a novel, or some other medium of fiction? If yes, what should be done to prevent it? If no, why not?
The story of the golem character teaches a lesson of keeping a moral perspective in our undertakings.
Aristotle's idea of catharsis meant that we should purge all sex and violence from art.
The Western Unforgiven with Clint Eastwood provides a strong pro-violence statement.
Name three didactic stories, describe their plots, and explain their moral lessons. Do you agree with these lessons? Why or why not?
Can Medea's actions be defended in any way? Is Jason free of blame? What do you think Euripides intended as his moral of the story?
Medea kills her own children to get back at her husband Jason for having left her.
The human purpose of storytelling in early, pretechnological cultures was to knit one's tribe firmly together by setting up the rules and boundaries that would establish a group identity.
Filters
- Essay(0)
- Multiple Choice(0)
- Short Answer(0)
- True False(0)
- Matching(0)