Two Interviewers Sit Down for a Discussion to Finalize the Candidate

Multiple Choice

Two interviewers sit down for a discussion to finalize the candidate to hire. Each of them nominates a different candidate as their "to-be-chosen" option. The discussion turns into a heated debate while they are comparing the two candidates. Which of the following issues is most likely to have led to the disagreement?

A) The interviewers agree that volunteer experience should not be a decision-critical attribute.
B) Neither candidate was eliminated in the pre-editing phase.
C) Although both were qualified, one candidate was more likable than the other candidate.
D) Both interviewers locked in prematurely on a different favored candidate.