Chris Gives You Two Reasons to Support an Implausible Claim

Multiple Choice

Chris gives you two reasons to support an implausible claim. One reason turns out to be irrelevant. As a strong critical thinker, what should you do?

A) Help Chris by making up another reason to support that claim.
B) Dismiss the second reason because the first was false.
C) Stop trusting anything Chris says.
D) Test the second reason.
E) Take Chris' claim on faith.