In Which of the Following Scenarios Would the Doctrine of Binding

Multiple Choice

In which of the following scenarios would the doctrine of binding precedent NOT apply?

A) A judge of the Superior Court of Justice of Ontario is hearing a case with similar facts and points of law to a case already decided by the Supreme Court of Canada
B) The Court of Appeal of Prince Edward Island is hearing a case with similar facts and points of laws to a case already decided by the Supreme Court of Canada.
C) A judge of the Supreme Court of British Columbia is hearing a case with similar facts and points of law to a case already decided by the Court of Appeal of British Columbia.
D) The Court of Appeal of Manitoba is hearing a case with similar facts and points of law to a case already decided by a judge of the Supreme Court of British Columbia.
E) It would apply in all of the above cases.