The Following Dispute: Dave

Multiple Choice

The following dispute: Dave:
I see in the paper that the man who has been in a persistent vegetative state for the past 12 years died yesterday.
Beth:
That's not correct. The man died 12 years ago when he permanently lost consciousness. It was only his body that died yesterday.
Is best described as:

A) Irresolvable.
B) Theological.
C) Verbal arising from vagueness.
D) Factual.
E) Verbal, arising from ambiguity.