For Which Argument Below Are the Premises Dependent

Multiple Choice

For which argument below are the premises dependent?

A) Premises: It is hot outside.Lemons are on sale.Conclusion: We should make lemonade.
B) Premises: Blanche can find a new boyfriend quickly.Rose didn't realize that she was dating Blanche's boyfriend.Conclusion: Blanche should forgive Rose.
C) Premises: My car needs expensive repairs.My car is too small.Conclusion: I should replace my car.
D) Premises: Birds depend on worms for nutrition.Worms depend on soil for nutrition.Conclusion: Birds depend on soil for nutrition.
E) Premises: Shooting stars are lucky.Shooting stars are beautiful.Conclusion: It would be good to see a shooting star.