If an Analogy Between a and B Suggests That B

Multiple Choice

If an analogy between A and B suggests that B has a property, but an analogy between B and C suggests that B doesn't have that property, then:

A) there is no way to know whether or not B has that property
B) the burden of proof is on the analogy between B and C, since the analogy between A and B was made first
C) the burden of proof is on the analogy between A and B, since the analogy between B and C challenged it
D) we decide between the two analogies by analyzing the strengths of their inductive components
E) we decide between the two analogies by analyzing the strengths of their deductive components