Are Probabilities Based on Intuitive Judgments Arbitrary and Indifferent to Evidence

Multiple Choice

Are probabilities based on intuitive judgments arbitrary and indifferent to evidence?

A) There are no probabilities based on intuitive judgments.
B) They are completely arbitrary, but they do take evidence into account.
C) They are not arbitrary, but they are completely indifferent to evidence.
D) Yes.
E) No.