Using the Same Data with SPSS, Jamie and John Found $\alpha$

Multiple Choice

Using the same data with SPSS, Jamie and John found out that the p value of an ANOVA F test is 0.004. They both rejected the null hypothesis. However, Jamie used $\alpha$ = 0.05, whereas John used $\alpha$ = 0.01. Who has a higher probability of actually making a Type I error?

A) Jamie
B) John
C) Both have the same probability.
D) Uncertain.