Which of the Following Is More Appealing? Why

Multiple Choice

Which of the following is more appealing? Why?
Stock X bought at $34 a share and sold for $36 in three months.
Stock Y bought at $120 a share and sold for $130 in six months.
No dividend is paid for either stock.

A) Y as it has a higher holding period percentage return
B) X because of the lower investment cost
C) X due to its higher effective annual return
D) Y since it provides a better dollar return
E) X and Y are equally attractive