Case Study Short Essay Examination Questions
Overcoming Regulatory Hurdles: Exelon Buys Constellation Energy
Key Points:
•Rising costs associated with more stringent environmental laws and the need to upgrade power grids are spurring consolidation in the fragmented U.S. electric utility industry.
•However, acquiring utilities often is particularly challenging due to the complex regulatory approval process.
______________________________________________________________________________
Reflecting increased demands for clean power, an aging electric power grid and other infrastructure, and the rising cost of fuels to generate power, the highly fragmented U.S. electric utility industry has undergone significant consolidation in recent years. By achieving increased scale, electric utilities are hoping to lower operating costs and gain the financial strength to finance the necessary investments in infrastructure and alternative energy sources. Utilities also are increasingly confronted by a combination of regulated and non-regulated electricity markets.
In most retail electricity markets in which electricity is sold directly to the end customer, rates that can be charged are regulated by local public utility commissions. While some utilities own their own generating capacity, others are dependent to varying degrees on purchasing electric power in the wholesale power market. A wholesale electricity market exists when competing HYPERLINK "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_generation" \o "Electricity generation" generators offer their electricity output to HYPERLINK "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_retailing" \o "Electricity retailing" retailers. Increasingly, large end-users can bypass retail electric utility companies to buy directly from wholesale power generators in a bid to access lower cost power by eliminating the middleman. Some states allow competition in their electricity markets while others do not. In competitive markets, power suppliers, including renewable and conventional oil and gas power generators, compete against each other to provide the best possible service at the lowest cost in order to attract and retain customers. In contrast, in monopoly-regulated states, power providers have no incentive to innovate or lower costs because ratepayers are captive to their monopoly-protected supplier.
Some utilities are attempting to shift to a mix of regulated and non-regulated electricity markets. The latest illustration of this strategy is Exelon Corp's acquisition of Constellation Energy for $7.9 billion in April 2011. The deal creates the largest electric utility and power generator in the U.S. The combined firm will gain stakes in five nuclear reactors and become the largest U.S. electricity marketer. Exelon is currently the largest owner and operator of U.S. nuclear plants and owns electric utilities Commonwealth Edison in Chicago and Peco Energy in Pennsylvania. Constellation owns the utility Baltimore Gas & Electric. Most of its revenue comes from the retail sale of electricity in states that allow competition. The merger creates the number one competitive energy provider with one of the industry's cleanest and lowest cost power generation plant systems in the country.
The combined company will keep the Exelon name and its headquarters in Chicago, as well as own more than 34 gigawatts of power generation. The company's power generation mix would be 55 percent nuclear, 24 percent natural gas, 6 percent hydro and renewable, and 7 percent oil, and 6 percent coal. Exelon will add 1.2 million electric customers in Constellation service areas.
This deal is Exelon's largest transaction. Exelon has tried unsuccessfully three times to buy other electric power companies since 2003. Exelon was thwarted by regulators in efforts to buy independent power producer NRG Energy in 2009, Public Service Enterprise Group in 2006, and Illinois Power in 2003. Constellation has been the target of two failed bids by other suitors. A $14.8 billion sale of Constellation to NextEra Energy Inc., the largest U.S. wind-power generator and owner of Florida's largest utility, collapsed in 2005.
Exelon announced on December 20, 2011 that it had received approval by the U.S. Justice Department to buy Constellation Energy Group Inc. The approval was contingent on Exelon selling three electricity generating plants in Maryland. The sale of the three power plants in the Baltimore area will significantly reduce the combined firm's market share in that region. The Justice Department believed that the combination, as originally proposed, would have lessened competition in the wholesale electricity market and increased prices for consumers in the Mid-Atlantic states (i.e., New York, Pennsylvania, and Maryland). Exelon and Constellation have also received regulatory approval from the Maryland and New York regulators as well as the Nuclear Regulatory Commission.
:
-What is anti-trust policy and why is it important? Why might its application be particularly important in the utility industry?

In a Tender Offer,which of the Following Is True

Multiple Choice

Correct Answer:VerifiedUnlock this answer nowGet Access to more Verified Answers free of chargeAccess For Free

Correct Answer:
Verified
Unlock this answer now
Get Access to more Verified Answers free of charge