Examine Elshtain's Reasons for Being Judgmental, and for Thinking Nonjudgmentalism

Question

Examlex · Accepted Answer

The Answer is Jean Bethke Elshtain, a political philosopher, argues that being judgmental is necessary for a functioning society and that nonjudgmentalism is "dangerous nonsense." She provides several reasons for this stance, which can be convincing to some extent.

First, Elshtain argues that being judgmental is essential for maintaining moral and ethical standards in society. Without the ability to make judgments about right and wrong, individuals and communities would have no basis for holding people accountable for their actions. This lack of accountability can lead to chaos and moral relativism, where anything goes and there are no consequences for harmful behavior. This argument can be convincing, as it highlights the importance of having a shared moral framework in society.

Second, Elshtain suggests that nonjudgmentalism can lead to a lack of critical thinking and discernment. She argues that being nonjudgmental can result in a reluctance to make moral distinctions and to confront difficult ethical questions. This can lead to a society that is unable to address and solve complex moral dilemmas, as people may shy away from making difficult decisions or taking a stand on important issues. This argument can also be convincing, as it emphasizes the need for individuals to engage in critical thinking and moral reasoning.

However, some may find Elshtain's reasons for being judgmental and her criticism of nonjudgmentalism to be less convincing. Critics may argue that being judgmental can lead to intolerance, prejudice, and discrimination, as individuals may use their judgments to justify harmful actions towards others. They may also argue that nonjudgmentalism can promote empathy, understanding, and acceptance of diverse perspectives, which are important for fostering a more inclusive and compassionate society.

In conclusion, while Elshtain's reasons for being judgmental and her critique of nonjudgmentalism may be convincing to some, they may also be subject to criticism. Ultimately, the debate over the value of being judgmental versus nonjudgmental is complex and multifaceted, and it is important to consider a range of perspectives on this issue.

Examine Elshtain's Reasons for Being Judgmental, and for Thinking Nonjudgmentalism

Essay

Correct Answer:
Answered by ExamLex AI

Examine Elshtain's Reasons for Being Judgmental, and for Thinking Nonjudgmentalism

Essay

Correct Answer:Answered by ExamLex AIShow Answer

Correct Answer:
Answered by ExamLex AI