How Would a Utilitarian Respond to the Suggestion That Alien

Question

Examlex · Accepted Answer

The Answer is From the standpoint of an act utilitarian, the response would likely be that allowing alien beings to abduct involuntary human subjects for lethal medical experiments in exchange for a cure for all viral diseases, including AIDS, would be justified if it resulted in the greatest overall happiness for the greatest number of people. In this case, the potential benefit of curing all viral diseases, including AIDS, could outweigh the harm caused to the involuntary human subjects. The act utilitarian would argue that the end result of maximizing happiness and minimizing suffering justifies the means of allowing the experiments to take place.

On the other hand, from the standpoint of a rule utilitarian, the response would likely be that allowing alien beings to abduct involuntary human subjects for lethal medical experiments would not be justified, even if it resulted in a cure for all viral diseases. This is because the rule utilitarian would argue that allowing such actions to take place could lead to a breakdown of societal rules and norms, ultimately leading to more harm than good. The rule utilitarian would prioritize following ethical rules and principles that promote the overall well-being of society, rather than focusing solely on the consequences of individual actions.

In conclusion, while an act utilitarian may argue that allowing the experiments could be justified based on the potential benefits, a rule utilitarian would likely argue that the potential harm caused by allowing such actions would outweigh any potential benefits.

How Would a Utilitarian Respond to the Suggestion That Alien

Essay

Correct Answer:
Answered by ExamLex AI

How Would a Utilitarian Respond to the Suggestion That Alien

Essay

Correct Answer:Answered by ExamLex AIShow Answer

Correct Answer:
Answered by ExamLex AI