Exam 8: Motor Vehicle Stops, Searches, and Inventories
Based on their research of 125 proven false confessions, Richard Leo and Steven Drizen concluded:
D
The right to remain silent is an ancient right.
True
Define "witness against himself," and give examples of what's included and not included within the definition.
The Fifth Amendment provides that in a criminal case a person can not be compelled to be a "witness against himself." This basically means that the government cannot force somebody to give evidence of a testimonial or a communicative nature. Testimony is the content of what a person says or writes. However the government can compel citizens to provide them with other information. When this information is not testimonial or communicative, but is rather of a physical nature or communications which the person has voluntarily reduced to writing, obtaining it does not violate the Fifth Amendment. Thus the following types of incriminating evidence would not be protected by the Fifth Amendment: handwriting samples, weapons, photographs, lineup appearances, voice samples, blood samples, and documents required to be kept by law or voluntarily created.
Ordering a suspect to speak so that a witness may try to identify the suspect's voice is covered by the Fifth Amendment self-incrimination clause.
The test for determining whether someone is in custody for purposes of Miranda is whether there was an arrest or restraint on freedom of movement to the degree associated with a formal arrest.
The Supreme Court's use of the Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination approach in reviewing state confession cases began with:
The constitutional bases for the law of confessions include:
I. due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.
II. Sixth Amendment right-to-counsel.
III. Eighth Amendment right against cruel and unusual punishment.
IV. Fifth Amendment right against self incrimination.
_____________ false confessions occur when vulnerable suspects confess under highly suggestive interrogation methods in order to end them, and come to believe they actually committed the crime.
Forced confessions are not admissible as evidence at trial because they are not trustworthy describes the .
In the 1936 Supreme Court case Brown v. Mississippi, involving the beating and torture of three black suspects to obtain a confession:
I. the Supreme Court declined to review a confession case from a state court.
II. the Supreme Court specifically relied upon the Fifth Amendment self incrimination clause.
III. the Supreme Court relied upon the Fourteenth Amendment due process clause.
IV. the Supreme Court held that forced confessions were not admissible as evidence.
According to the Supreme Court opinion in New York v. Quarles, involving a confession without Miranda warnings following an armed rape of a young woman:
I. there is a public safety exception to the requirement that police give Miranda warnings.
II. the availability of the public safety exception does not depend on the motivation of the individual officers involved.
III. the public safety exception weakens the clarity of the Miranda rule.
IV. the need for answers to questions in a situation posing a threat to public safety outweighs the need for the rule protecting the privilege against self-incrimination.
In applying the definition of custodial interrogation to actual cases, which of the following circumstances are relevant to determining if a suspect is in custody?
I. whether officers had probable cause to arrest
II. whether the investigation had focused on the suspect at the time
III. the officers' language in summoning suspects
IV. the physical surroundings of the interrogation
When a suspect asks for an attorney during custodial interrogation:
In screening the police procedures that are used during the accusatory stage of the criminal process, the courts recognize:
In Berkemer v. McCarty, the case involving whether Miranda warnings must be given to stopped motorists, the Court:
According to the Supreme Court in Miranda v. Arizona, when must the police stop an interrogation?
I. when the suspect indicates doubt about the crime and the circumstances
II. when the suspect requests an attorney
III. when the suspect indicates, in any manner, that they wish to remain silent
IV. when the suspect requests to see their spouse
The period of criminal process when police shift from a general investigation to building a case against a particular suspect is known as _____________.
According to the Supreme Court's decision in Miranda v. Arizona, custodial interrogation is inherently coercive.
Filters
- Essay(0)
- Multiple Choice(0)
- Short Answer(0)
- True False(0)
- Matching(0)