Exam 30: Whether One Is Allowed to Kill Oneself Excerpts

Correct Answer:

Answered by Examlex AI Copilot

Aquinas' response to the argument that suicide is morally permissible when done to avoid a greater harm or evil is rooted in his belief that human life is a gift from God and that it is not within our rights to take our own lives. He argues that suicide is a violation of the natural inclination to preserve one's own life, which is a fundamental aspect of human nature.

Aquinas also emphasizes the importance of the virtue of fortitude, which is the moral strength to endure suffering and adversity. He argues that choosing suicide to avoid a greater harm or evil is a sign of weakness and a lack of fortitude, as it fails to confront and overcome the challenges of life.

In my opinion, Aquinas' response is convincing because it is based on a strong ethical and theological foundation. His emphasis on the sanctity of human life and the importance of moral virtues provides a compelling argument against the permissibility of suicide, even in the face of great suffering. Additionally, his perspective aligns with many religious and philosophical traditions that value the inherent worth and dignity of human life. Overall, Aquinas' response offers a thought-provoking and compelling perspective on the moral implications of suicide.