Exam 5: C: Socialization

Correct Answer:

Answered by Examlex AI Copilot

Carol Gilligan, an American feminist, ethicist, and psychologist, is best known for her work on moral development and ethical relationships. In her influential book "In a Different Voice" (1982), Gilligan challenged the universality of Lawrence Kohlberg's stages of moral development, which were based on studies conducted primarily with male subjects. She argued that Kohlberg's model did not adequately represent the moral reasoning of women.

Gilligan's research suggested that there are differences in how males and females make moral judgments, which she attributed to the different socialization and experiences of men and women. According to Gilligan, these differences can be summarized as follows:

1. **Ethic of Care vs. Ethic of Justice**: Gilligan proposed that males tend to adopt an "ethic of justice" which emphasizes rules, rights, and formal logic. This approach is more abstract and focuses on principles of fairness and equality. In contrast, females are more likely to adopt an "ethic of care," which emphasizes relationships, responsibilities, and compassion. This approach is more contextual and considers the needs of others and the nuances of particular situations.

2. **Response to Moral Dilemmas**: When faced with moral dilemmas, Gilligan found that males were more likely to prioritize abstract principles and the application of justice, whereas females were more inclined to consider the complexities of relationships and the care of individuals involved. For example, in the famous Heinz dilemma, where a man considers stealing a drug to save his wife's life, males might focus on the legality of the action and the importance of upholding the law, while females might focus on the importance of preserving life and the relationships affected by the decision.

3. **Moral Development**: Gilligan argued that Kohlberg's model of moral development, with its emphasis on justice and rights, did not capture the full range of moral reasoning that women employ. She suggested that women's moral development might follow a different trajectory, one that emphasizes the growth of care-based ethics and the understanding of relationships.

4. **Voice and Perspective**: Gilligan contended that women's moral voices were often undervalued or not heard within a society that privileges male-oriented perspectives. She advocated for recognizing the legitimacy and importance of the female moral perspective, which includes empathy, compassion, and an emphasis on maintaining social bonds.

It is important to note that Gilligan's work has been both influential and controversial. Critics have argued that her findings may overgeneralize or essentialize gender differences, and that moral reasoning may not be as gendered as her theory suggests. Subsequent research has shown that both men and women can and do employ both care and justice orientations, and that individual differences in moral reasoning are influenced by a variety of factors, including but not limited to gender.

Nonetheless, Gilligan's contributions have sparked significant discussion and have led to a broader understanding of moral development that includes multiple voices and perspectives. Her work has also had a lasting impact on fields such as ethics, psychology, education, and gender studies.