Exam 2: Evidence-Based Practice
Explain why the evidence-based practice process is thought by some to be an overly restrictive cookbook approach that hinders the treatment alliance and why others counter that such a notion is based on a misconception of the evidence-based practice process.
The evidence-based practice process is sometimes thought to be an overly restrictive cookbook approach that hinders the treatment alliance because it is seen as rigid and inflexible. Some practitioners believe that following a strict set of guidelines and protocols can limit their ability to tailor treatment to the individual needs and preferences of their clients. They argue that this approach can undermine the therapeutic relationship and diminish the client's sense of autonomy and empowerment in the treatment process.
On the other hand, others counter that such a notion is based on a misconception of the evidence-based practice process. They argue that evidence-based practice is not about blindly following a set of rules, but rather about integrating the best available research evidence with clinical expertise and the client's values and preferences. They emphasize that evidence-based practice allows for flexibility and individualization in treatment, and that it actually strengthens the treatment alliance by promoting transparency, collaboration, and shared decision-making between the practitioner and the client.
Furthermore, proponents of evidence-based practice argue that it is essential for ensuring that clients receive the most effective and ethical care possible. They assert that evidence-based practice is not about restricting practitioners, but rather about empowering them to make informed and ethical decisions that are in the best interest of their clients. They emphasize that evidence-based practice is a dynamic and evolving process that encourages practitioners to continually evaluate and improve their practice based on the best available evidence. Therefore, they argue that the perception of evidence-based practice as overly restrictive is based on a misunderstanding of its principles and goals.
The evidence-based practice model encourages practitioners to integrate scientific evidence with their practice expertise.
True
Practitioners engaged in evidence-based practice will
E
Whether practitioners need to evaluate the intervention they apply depends on how strong the existing research evidence is that supports that intervention.
The evidence supporting the influence of common factors on treatment outcome implies that the choice of intervention does not matter at all.
Explain why the evaluation phase (the final phase)of the evidence-based practice process is important even when applying an intervention that has been supported by the best research evidence.
It is necessary to choose either a top-down or a bottom-up approach to searching for evidence; it is incorrect to use both approaches in the same search.
Which of the following statements is/are true about evidence-based practice?
The top-down approach to searching for evidence has the advantage of feasibility but can be risky in light of the fallibility and possible bias of experts.
Any study that employs a randomized clinical trial is a strong source of evidence,regardless of how it measures outcome.
If an intervention has been supported by the best evidence,then it is safe to assume that it will be effective with a particular client.
Some evidence-based practice questions do not specify a particular intervention in advance of the search for evidence.
If one finds that no quality research studies exist to answer one's EBP question,then no additional phase of the EBP process is needed.
The term evidence-based practice is an extension of the term evidence-based medicine,which predated it.
Explain why the evidence-based practice process is important even if no quality outcome studies have ever been conducted that pertain to a client or particular practice situation.(Hint: The last phase of the evidence-based practice process should be an important part of your essay).
Filters
- Essay(0)
- Multiple Choice(0)
- Short Answer(0)
- True False(0)
- Matching(0)